Well, Entergy of Louisiana can’t keep the valves at the plant oiled but they do keep their legal team lubricated with money. Entergy’s legal team was successful in the challenge to Vermont’s law covering Vermont Yankee operating past 2012. The Times-Argus reports Entergy has sent a message from New Orleans demanding Vermont pay $4.6 million in legal fees they claim they incurred in the suit against the State.
Reacting to this news Vermont Attorney General William Sorrell said he had thought the claim from Entergy would be “in seven figures” more in line with Vermont standards. The Attorney General says:
“I guess it [$4.6 million] shows the ‘David-versus-Goliath’ aspect of the case,”
The mismatch is suitable but it’s kind of an ill fit otherwise for this situation as Goliath has won and is now making demands from David after this part of battle.
It also seems Sorrel had a surprising hope. Against all past dealings with Goliath he thought Entergy might make a gesture of being a good corporate citizen to atone for sins of the past.
Sorrell said he had even thought Entergy might not seek legal fees in a gesture of being “a good corporate citizen making up for the sins of the past and the misleading statements about the underground pipes.”
Sorrell had investigated Entergy officials for more than a year for possible criminal charges for the misstatements about underground pipes, which were later found to be the source of radioactive tritium leaking at the plant in 2010. Entergy executives had said such pipes did not exist.
Under pressure they grudgingly admitted to miscommunicating about underground pipes. No criminal charges were filed; no case was brought so why would Entergy feel it had sinned? Hardly sinning in Goliath’s book of rules, maybe in the eyes of Entergy Corp the only sin is losing.
There’s still round two & three if the losing party in round two takes it to SCOTUS. OT Goliath didn’t get to appeal the ruling.
And, states have their own laws which include regulations regarding entities operating in their state in this case Entergy Louisiana’s VY.
NY gov Andrew Cuomo has vowed to shutter Indian Point in no uncertain terms. NY State is enforcing its water quality laws & has already told Entergy it must use ALL their cooling towers, a huge expense. VT can also do this. In VT it is as high as $1 million per day, I’m told this is their entire profit.
I’m not happy, but not worried. Those who live by the sword die by the sword, usually by falling on it. The bigger they come the harder they fall.