mug     

Please Donate To the Greater Falls Warming Shelter in Memory of Julie Waters



Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?

Search




Advanced Search


Active Users
Currently 1 user(s) logged on.




Not guilty, by reason of incompetence?

by: Sue Prent

Mon Jul 11, 2011 at 00:31:51 AM EDT


This week, Reuters reported on the growing credibility gap among Japanese with regard to the ethical reliability of their nuclear industry as a whole, even as the Fukushima disaster remains unresolved.  

With Tokyo Electric already discredited, the industry has been further tarnished by revelations that Kyushu Electric Power Co. attempted to manipulate a public forum on nuclear safety by instructing its workers to pose as ordinary citizens and send e-mails in support of restarting nuclear power plants in the south.

"There is growing suspicion that power companies are playing fast and loose with data to support their cause and will go so far as to orchestrate public support," said Jeffrey Kingston, director of Asian studies at Temple University's Japan campus.

To their credit, the Japanese public actually seem surprised and outraged by this effrontery!  Over here, we've just come to expect such unethical behavior as a matter of course.

There's little comfort for Vermonters in Attorney General William Sorrell's conclusion that Entergy and Vermont Yankee's misrepresentations do not exactly rise to the level of criminal behavior.  As the Free Press observed today,  incompetence in the administration of a nuclear facility is hardly more desirable than downright dishonesty.

"We found more incompetence than malevolence," Attorney General William Sorrell said this week in announcing the results of the investigation. "A corporation of this size and this importance -- I don't mean to disparage cops -- but this was like Keystone Kops."

In a sane world, where concerns for public safety would trump all corporate claims, this finding would be...should be... the final nail in the coffin for Vermont Yankee.  

But, no...if the Attorney General thinks he can't make a criminal case out of the whoppers perpetrated by Entergy and VY, we just go on as if nothing ever happened; and the NRC doesn't even care that the operators have been publicly exposed (at the very least) as colossal incompetents.

Isn't this sort of the corporate equivalent of claiming innocence by reason of insanity?  

Sue Prent :: Not guilty, by reason of incompetence?
Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Raise Your Voice!

I don't get the sense that this is a "win" for Entergy (0.00 / 0)
Surely it is avoiding what would've been a monumental loss had they really brought charges, but having your business declared grossly incompetent - as everyone has been saying for a while now - seems to leave them in the same place they were before AG Sorrell's press conference.

IMO, maybe a more fitting analogy is a lazy shopowner, who, despite his son's repeated dangerous mistakes running the business, and his unwillingness to fess up to them, continues to allow the kid to oversee important operations.  Even though it is obvious he's in for more of the same and doesn't want to go through that, he keeps employing him because he doesn't want to go through the messy process of firing his son, hiring someone new for the position, and helping them get started.

tl;dr: can't expect different results with the same people - especially when those people are found "incompetent" by the AG

mbreuer.vt@gmail.com


Not guilty, by reason of incompetence (0.00 / 0)
It may not be a "win" for Entergy but wouldn't it be nice and comforting if Attorney General Sorrel could bring home a "win" for Vermont once in while.  

[ Parent ]
Entergy "wins" every month past March 2012 (4.00 / 2)
that they keep drawing revenue from VY.  And the unwaivering support they enjoy from the NRC, in the face of all the damning evidence, enables them to pursue legal remedies that will likely make that possible for some time, even if they ultimately lose.

I understand that Bill Sorrell may feel he is acting conservatively on behalf of the state, but I wonder if it wouldn't be more valuable in the long run to have the whole sordid tail pulled out of it's hidey-hole in a high-profile courtroom drama that both the public and shareholders can follow.

That likely won't happen at any point in the purely technical arguments over the Legislature's rights that  will be vetted in the challenge that Entergy is bringing against the state.  Remember, legally, we are not even allowed to address issues of safety.


[ Parent ]
Liars' Guidebook for Corporados by Bill Sorrell (4.00 / 4)
Well, every corporation in Vermont now has access to the convenient Liars' Guidebook for Corporados compiled by Bill Sorrell. To avoid prosecution for perjury by Sorrell's AG office, all any deceit-minded executive or manager has to say in response to any question in any public or government hearing, under oath or not, is "I believe there are no pipes ... I believe there is no threat to any water supply. ... To the best of my belief there are no cracks in any pipes or containment structures. ... I believe any minor cooling tower leakage is related to stress on wooden structures. ... I believe my corporation would never cut safety corners in pursuit of profit."

Riiiiiiiight.

NanuqFC
In a Time of Universal Deceit, TELLING the TRUTH Is a Revolutionary Act. ~ George Orwell


[ Parent ]
Amazing that... (4.00 / 2)
...these fuckos can do what they do.  Energy Terrorism.  Not covered by the Patriot Laws.  Threats to the public safety?--Hey, dudes, get a life.  bin Laden missed his calling.  

Ineresting op-eds (4.00 / 1)
show that this was no win for Entergy Louisiana by any means. Free Press notes that since their first call for VY shutdown, nothing Entergy has done changes this position.

Reformer has a double-edged sword kind of take which mocks Entergy's present action - the injunction in which Judge Murtha must perform the impossible, determine what was on the minds of lawmakers when crafting legislation:

You can't have it both ways
Posted: 07/08/2011 10:23:49 AM
Friday, July 8, 2011

"Some critics of Vermont Attorney General Bill Sorrell's decision to not pursue perjury charges against Vermont Yankee representatives are upset they weren't interviewed during his 17-month investigation. They rightfully contend that they could have provided Sorrell with background information on the issue of buried and underground pipes at the nuclear power plant in Vernon."


http://www.reformer.com/reform...
Free Press:
Voice of the Free Press: Attorney general's report adds to worries about Vermont Yankee
6:34 AM, Jul. 10, 2011  

"[..]When it comes to running a nuclear power plant, being called "incompetent" -- the idea that you couldn't get it right even if you tried -- is a truly severe indictment under the circumstances."


http://www.burlingtonfreepress...

Throw Sorrell out (4.00 / 2)
Bill Sorrell is far too comfortable as life time Attorney General and far too comfortable with power. The Keystone Kops running a nuclear facility IS a crime.
Whether the AG is an activist or not makes all the difference. Sorrell is too complacent and familiar with all the players and not likely to rock any boats. I'll bet he's on DOJ's side in settling with the banks on the mortgage crimes rather than really investigating. We need new blood that will go after the powerful criminals who think they own our world. Charlotte Dennett would fit that bill.

peggy luhrs


GMD Links

Vermont Daily Briefing
Rational Resistance
VT News Guy
VT Digger
Minor Heresies
What's the Point?
Vermont Yankee, evacuation plans, & more
Mulish Behavior
Political Animal (with Steve Benen)
Reason and Brimstone
Blazing Indiscretions
sneigwh
Dohiyi Mir
Blier Watch
five before chaos
Blue Hampshire
Blue News Tribune
Burlington Pol
Norsehorse
Rip & Read
Integral Psychosis
VT Secession
Tenselblog
VT Bloggernaut
Morgan's Gov. race blog
Bureaucracy Blog
Austanspace

Non-political

Candleblog
iBrattleboro
WKVT 1490 AM
Vermont Mornings
False 45th
Bosox Wally

National

Congress Matters
Daily Kos
Open Left
BlogPac
Talking Points Memo
My Left Wing
MyDD
Docudharma
Glenn Greenwald
Firedoglake
Atrios (Eschaton)
Think Progress
Driftglass
Pam's House Blend
Hullabaloo (Digby)
The Plum Line (Sargent)

Legacy Media Blogs

Vermont View
vt buzz
Blurt (7 Days)

International

The Irish Independent
Comment is free...(Guardian UK)
Al Jazeera
Pulse Media
Global Voices
All Voices
Vermonters for a Just Peace in Israel/Palestine




Specialized Feeds:

Google Reader or Homepage
Add to My Yahoo!
Subscribe with Bloglines
Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Add to My AOL
Subscribe in Rojo
R|Mail
Add to Technorati Favorites!


RSS FEED


blog advertising is good for you
Event Calendar
May 2012
(view month)
S M T W R F S
* * 01 02 03 04 05
06 07 08 09 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 * *
<< (add event) >>

Follow us on Twitter! or Like us on Facebook!


Featured Stories
State and Local
National and International




Powered by: SoapBlox