My City Clerk Race: A Little Help From my Friends?

Well, I wasn’t going to do this – but it looks like I’ll be running against at least 1, and possibly as many as 3, opponents for the Montpelier City Clerk position. SO as part of my GMD farewell tour, I’m putting an ask out there for folks who might want to support me in my career change.

As a database guy, I see a lot of opportunities to minimize the mounds of paper that tend to consume the office, and possibly introduce new efficiencies in the process. I would also like to look at ways to make the office into the “mini Secretary of State” that it is in the community – possibly running voter registration drives out of City Hall.

Anyway, I’d appreciate any support you can share, as it’s 4 short weeks til Town Meeting Day. Click the button below to give what you can (if you give $100 or more I’ll have to follow up with you and get your employer info). Thanks a lot for your help in this. It’s new territory for me.





2012 State of the State Address

Here is the text of Governor Shumlin’s State of the State Address to the Legislature:

Mr. President, Mr. Speaker, Mr. Chief Justice, Members of the General Assembly, distinguished guests, fellow Vermonters:

Thank you. It’s been such a privilege to serve as Vermont’s governor over the past year. Our partnership of community, courage, and common purpose that has empowered us through the unprecedented challenges dumped upon us by Mother Nature, combined with our willingness to make the tough choices necessary to grow jobs and economic opportunities for all Vermonters, has made us stronger.

I want to recognize a few of the thousands of Vermonters who have made us so proud in the last year, and serve as symbols of Vermont at its best.

We are so grateful to the dedicated women and men of our armed forces, whose service both overseas and during the Irene recovery has been exemplary. Please join me in honoring our Vermont troops, led by Gen. Michael Dubie.

The magnitude of devastation from Tropical Storm Irene astounded General Dubie and me as we landed in community after community in the days after the storm. I knew that we needed effective, experienced leaders to help us cut through bureaucracy and rebuild at breakneck speed as we raced winter weather. I am so grateful to our Irene Recovery Officer Neale Lunderville, who took a leave from his job to join our team in Vermont’s time of need. Neale, all Vermonters join me in thanking you for your selfless service to the state you love.

This has been an especially tough year for Vermont’s local government leaders. I want to acknowledge four of our storm-tested, hard-working mayors: Thom Lauzon, Barre; Marty Manahan, St. Albans; Chris Louras, Rutland; Mary Hooper, Montpelier: please stand so we can acknowledge your service to Vermont.

I also want to acknowledge an outstanding legal mind and a pioneer in civil rights who made history this year by joining the Vermont Supreme Court. Justice Robinson, thank you for your service to justice in Vermont.  

***

Today I report to you on the state of the greatest state in the nation, one that has demonstrated over the course of the past year what it means to be united as one community to overcome tragedy. In the wake of a deep recession, two spring storms, and a tropical storm that devastated our infrastructure and exacted an unimaginable toll on the lives of thousands of Vermonters, I can tell you without reservation or exaggeration: the state of our state is strong. Vermont strong!

From Halifax to Hartford, Wilmington to Waterbury, Roxbury to Richmond, the hundreds of individual actions of bravery and courage in the days and months after Irene will be forever etched in my memory. I want to share one of them.

Rutland Mayor Chris Louras, who like most local leaders was working long days without sleep after Irene, called me every few hours with progress updates on the unfolding tragedy – the search for Mike Garofano and his son, who went missing during the storm. With Route 4 nothing but a streambed in sections where roadway once ran, I came in by National Guard helicopter to join Mayor Louras and give son Tommy Garofano a bear hug from all Vermonters.

Tommy’s dad, Mike Sr., grew up in Rutland and went to work for the city for over 30 years, rising to become the manager of the water plant, a job to which he dedicated his life. Mike and his wife Sally had two sons – Mike Jr., known also as Little Mike, and Tommy; Mike also had a son Robby. Robby lost his life in a tragic accident in 2010, and Little Mike and Tommy’s tight bond with their mom and dad helped them all in the face of such adversity.

On the evening of Irene, with Mendon Brook raging, Mike and Little Mike braved through the storm to the water plant to check on the inlet valve that Mike had closed the previous day to make sure polluted water would not enter the city’s reservoir. It was a risk, but they were determined to protect Rutland’s water supply. With Mendon Brook carving craters where solid soil once stood, the banks gave way, sweeping them both away. Mike’s body was retrieved the next day, but the search for Little Mike went on for weeks.

While Sally was comforted by family and friends, Tommy heroically joined the search and rescue effort, digging through mountains of Irene’s debris looking for his brother.

Today on behalf of our state, we honor two Vermont heroes, Michael Garofano and Michael Garofano, Jr. with a promise that we will never forget. Joining us in the chamber are Sally and Tommy Garofano.

To Sally and Tommy — and the families of the six other Vermonters who lost their lives as a result of Tropical Storm Irene — our admiration and support will never cease. Thank you.

As Mayor Louras and I gave what comfort we could to Tommy on that day at Mendon Brook, something else happened that characterizes Vermont strong. With Route 4 shut down, and community after community isolated islands where roads and bridges once served, brothers John and Doug Casella had an idea. Doug said, “Governor, you get the Department of Motor Vehicles to lift the ban on hauling heavy equipment across what’s left of our roads and get us permission to retrieve some of the rock and gravel that Irene washed from our roads into our streams, and we’ll partner with other private contractors like Belden Company, Markowski Excavating, Mosher Excavating, Wilk Paving, the Agency of Transportation and the National Guard. We can have Route 4 open in three weeks.”

As soon as I got high enough in the chopper to actually have cell service in Vermont, I called Secretary Searles, Secretary Markowitz and Commissioner Ide, and within hours, our team applied Doug’s request, not just to Rutland, but to the whole state of Vermont. And guess what? Nine days later, Route 9 from Brattleboro to Wilmington to Bennington: Open. 18 days later, Route 4 from Woodstock to Rutland: Open. And today, all the roads destroyed by Irene: Open!

Team Casella, Belden, Wilk, Mosher, Markowski are here today, and I would ask you to please stand. You represent the many Vermont construction companies who, along with AOT, the Vermont National Guard and Guard troops from around the country rebuilt us Vermont Strong, and Vermont honors you today.

In this public/private partnership, with winter looming, we did it right, with Vermont ingenuity, fiscal prudence, and common sense. We rebuilt, for 35 cents on the dollar, bringing total estimated damage down to $250 million for state roads and infrastructure, and $140 million for town roads. Thanks to the skill of the best Congressional delegation in America, Senator Leahy, Senator Sanders and Congressman Welch, the Leahy amendment became law, ensuring that Vermont will get the federal aid we need in our time of need, reducing our projected cost to the General Fund to under $30 million. Please join me in recognizing the great work of Senator Patrick Leahy, Senator Bernie Sanders, and Congressman Peter Welch as well as our partners at FEMA.

***

There are two Irene lessons that we must seize from our experience over the past four months.

The first lesson is clear: if after Irene we can rebuild over 500 miles of damaged roads and 34 bridges in four months for a fraction of normal cost, with dwindling federal funds in our future, we must apply those lessons to maintaining and rebuilding Vermont’s aging transportation infrastructure from this point forward. We will build faster, smarter, and more economically.

Instead of having state workers bunkered in their individual agencies, processing paper, we broke down the silos, forming a partnership between AOT, ANR, private contractors, and municipalities. Contracting procedures were modified; access to stone and gravel was expedited; dangerous debris was removed from brooks and streams as engineers worked together with environmental experts to get the job done. Projects that pre-Irene would have taken years got done in months; environmental quality was preserved; taxpayer dollars were saved; and roads and bridges were built to withstand the assault of extreme weather that looms even larger in our future.

The second lesson comes from the remarkable tenacity of the hundreds of small businesses that were drowned in water and mud, putting hard working Vermonters out of work overnight. A year ago at this podium, I pledged the following: My jobs agenda will expand the ability of emerging entrepreneurs and businesses to get access to capital when they need it most.

When Lt. Gov. Phil Scott and I traveled the state together, reaching out to the hundreds of small businesses shuttered by triple storms, our message to job creators was: We stand by you, we stand with you, and the state of Vermont will do its part in helping you get back on your feet.

Partnering with the Vermont Economic Development Authority, we created an emergency low interest loan program that, with minimal bureaucracy and maximum effectiveness, got credit of up to $100,000 to crippled job creators within days. More than 340 businesses and farms were granted loans, totaling $15.3 million. With liquidity, Vermont ingenuity and hard work, miracle after miracle happened as business after business reopened.

· Bartleby’s Bookstore in Wilmington: Open

· Leader Home Center in Brattleboro: Open

· Simon Pierce in Windsor: Open

· The Red Wagon Toy Company in Woodstock: Open

· Winhall Market in Bondville: Open

· Sunrise General Store in Bridgewater Corners: Open

· Wall-Goldfinger in Northfield: Open

· Nelson Hardware in Barre: Open

· The Rochester Café: Open

· American Flatbread in Waitsfield: Open

· Positive Pie in Montpelier: Open

And the list goes on and on. The lesson for Vermont government in helping to grow jobs in Vermont is simple: Getting credit to entrepreneurs when they need it most grows prosperity and grows jobs. In fact, there is nothing standing in the way of Vermont’s job creators that cannot be made right by a partnership with state government that is built on a foundation of common sense, trust, and expedited risk credit for businesses when others won’t lend.

Vermont’s response to Irene perfectly illustrates the strong state of our state. Perhaps the greatest lesson that we can take from the challenge of the previous four months is that despite Irene’s devastation, despite our heartbreak and pain, we are bound by common purpose.

We are also bound by tragic loss. To the hundreds of Vermonters who lost so much – lost their house, lost their belongings, lost the land that their homes rested on or the land they tilled, we stand with you in the long recovery that lies ahead, to help you close the gap between your hopes and dreams that were washed away and the paltry $30,200 maximum reimbursement afforded you by our federal government. While we know that we can never make you whole, our resolve as your neighbors and friends to continue to help you rebuild your lives remains as strong as ever.

We are so grateful to everyone who has stepped up and contributed, from the students at Moretown Elementary School who passed a jar in class to the countless church groups, non-profits and private companies who have contributed millions of dollars. Vermont musicians like Phish and Grace Potter held concerts that raised well over $1 million, and Tony Pomerleau, who just recently pledged a very generous $1 million to the Vermont Disaster Relief Fund. At a youthful 93, Tony is here today. Tony, we thank you for your generosity.  

Vermonters have been so generous, but we have many miles to travel before we rest and many dollars to raise before we sleep. In that spirit, we are pleased to introduce our new Vermont Strong license plates, which can be purchased at vtstrong.vermont.gov. If you purchase this plate for the front of your vehicle, the proceeds will go to the Vermont Disaster Relief Fund to help those who need us.

***

I could devote this entire speech to our recovery, because I do believe that Tropical Storm Irene represents a defining moment in Vermont’s history. But now is our moment to apply that same courage, strength and ingenuity to our most pressing need: growing jobs and prosperity for all Vermonters.

Having witnessed what Vermont can do together, I have never been more optimistic about our ability to keep getting tough things done to help us grow jobs in 2012.

If we can rebuild destroyed roads and bridges in less than four months, we can meet my promise of connecting every corner of Vermont to high speed internet and vastly improved cell service by the end of 2013. In the past year, we have connected 7,500 locations, and installed 1,600 miles of fiber in our ongoing effort to connect Vermont.  We are going to keep our promise of closing Vermont’s connectivity gap and we are going to grow jobs as we connect.

If we can rebuild our transportation infrastructure at 35 cents on the dollar, we can lead the nation in arresting the skyrocketing cost of health care that is hurting job growth and picking the pockets of our struggling middle class. Your Green Mountain Health Board is hard at work building that system now.

If we can reopen hundreds of flooded businesses in 14 weeks, we can transform Vermont into the innovative education leader, where from early childhood to higher education to continuing education, we train employees for the prosperous jobs of our future. In my budget address next week, in addition to addressing the challenges and opportunities of replacing our state hospital and state office complex, I will propose significant state investments in higher education and dual enrollment, all aimed at making Vermont students even more competitive and creating opportunities for employers to recruit the employees they are now seeking.

If we can turn the lights back on in just three days for over 70,000 utility customers, thanks to the heroic work of our utilities, we can create jobs by harnessing the sun, wind, water, forests and fields to produce community-generated renewable power. We have made progress this past year, but we need to keep building. This session, I will propose requiring an affordable and achievable Renewable Energy Portfolio standard that sets a goal to obtain 75 percent renewable electricity in 20 years. I will also recommend that Vermont build on our Standard Offer program so that we can build faster.

If we can reconnect hundreds of miles of washed out dirt roads in just days so that milk trucks can get to our dairy farmers who had to dump milk during the storm, we can create jobs by fueling the renaissance in locally grown Vermont food. This year we will continue to focus on farm to plate, farm to fork, buy local, and farmer’s markets, while addressing the challenge of producing enough Vermont-grown milk to meet the needs of our value-added dairy companies.

If we can build partnerships between state and municipal governments to keep our citizens safe and secure, we can work together to address two of the most serious problems we face: winning the war on recidivism, and stemming the epidemic abuse of prescription drugs, particularly opiates, that is driving crime and destroying the lives of too many of our neighbors.

Next week, I will also propose changes to our Prescription Drug Monitoring System. Access to the system by law enforcement needs to recognize an individual’s right to privacy while giving law enforcement the tools they need to track down abusive access so we can fight our prescription drug epidemic. This growing problem is so frightening because while FDA-approved prescription opiates are easy to get, many are just as addicting and dangerous as street heroin and crack cocaine.

***

Since taking office a year ago, I have visited countless businesses throughout the state, and met with small business owners, from Bo Muller-Moore who had a simple idea to put the phrase “Eat More Kale” on t-shirts and now works 14 hour days to fill orders from across the country, to Briar and Adam Alpert of BioTek, a global leader in medical applications technology. I am so optimistic about our jobs future, and every day I see evidence of Vermont’s entrepreneurial success.

But we have a lot more work to do. Too many Vermonters continue to struggle to make ends meet for themselves and their families.

But to those who say that Vermont is a bad place to do business, that our bold policies for job growth aren’t getting results, that our optimism about Vermont’s jobs future is not matched by progress, I ask you to consider these facts: our unemployment rate at the peak of the recession was 7.3 percent; today it is among the lowest in America at 5.3 percent. Chittenden County now enjoys the fourth lowest unemployment rate in America. Over the past year, new jobs in Vermont grew by 62 percent over the prior year, more than any other state in the nation. Vermont ranked second in a recent study of how well states use tax breaks and economic development subsidies to actually create jobs.

If you don’t believe the data, I invite you to join me on the road, reaching out to Vermont’s job creators. Here are a few that I have visited this year.

In Newport, Bill Stenger is working on several projects in Orleans County in addition to building a world class four-season resort at Jay Peak that employs hundreds of Vermonters. Bill and his partners are bringing Anc/Bio and four other new projects that represent a $350 million investment and will produce 3,000 direct and indirect jobs in the heart of the Northeast Kingdom.

In Rutland, GE continues to expand one of the largest GE manufacturing plants of jet engines in the nation for both commercial and military aircraft.

In Castleton, Hubbardton Forge is on track to meet its goal of doubling its sales in five years.

In Barre, SB Electronics is up and running, with capacity to produce parts for 100,000 plug-in hybrid vehicles within three years.

In Essex, Green Mountain Coffee Roasters is building a new plant that will employ hundreds of additional Vermonters and help fuel the exceptional growth of one of America’s most successful companies.

Next door in Essex Junction, IBM continues to innovate and create the jobs of the future. Vermont’s IBM plant is thriving and adding jobs, and is now one of the world’s largest producers of semiconductor technology, employing 6,000 people.

In Arlington, Mack Molding continues to hire and expand.

In Vergennes, Goodrich is hiring.

In Essex Junction, Revision Eyewear is thriving and has developed a new combat helmet that, if adopted by the U.S. military, will allow them to vastly expand manufacturing in Vermont.

In Newport, Louis Garneau will be building new facilities to expand manufacturing jobs.

From the Massachusetts line to the Canadian border, companies that opened this year include Commonwealth Yogurt in Brattleboro, Farmstead Cheese in Woodstock, Swan Valley Cheese in Swanton, and many other small value-added agricultural businesses are growing their customer base, creating jobs, and adding vitality to a dairy industry that is poised for revitalization.

My administration and I commit ourselves every day to attracting entrepreneurs and growing jobs, one job at a time, as we slowly but surely grow our way out of the most painful recession in our nation’s history.

Let me say one more word about staying competitive and creating jobs. Our tax policy has a direct impact on our jobs future. You may have heard me say this before: Vermont’s problem is not that our taxes are not high enough; it is that our taxes are too high.

I am a proud and strong supporter of Vermont’s progressive income tax structure – the most progressive in the country, where unlike the federal government, we require our wealthiest citizens to pay their fair share of income tax. But, we cannot correct the tax failures of Washington from the State House in Montpelier, and we must be always mindful that every day, we compete with our neighboring states for jobs. Therefore, I remain determined not to increase broad-based taxes on Vermonters as we begin to see signs of modest economic growth.

***

Looking back on the last year, we have so much to be thankful for, and so many opportunities ahead.

As we enter this new year, partisanship continues to paralyze our democracy in Washington, DC. At a time when many of America’s cities and communities beyond Vermont’s borders often seem more divided than united, our little state has distinguished itself. Indeed, there is nothing wrong with America that could not be made right by the ingenuity and caring spirit of the people of the state of Vermont. By continuing to set aside what divides us and finding common ground to unite us, we will rebuild our state while making the bold decisions that will lead to continued job growth and a bright future for Vermont.

Let’s get back to work. Thank you.  

Little ‘RED’ Hen

(An Election Year Nursery Un-Rhyme)

Who will help me save the Schools from Wall Street?

Not I, said the President, for I am Under Orders

And not I, said the Liberal, for I support the President

Well, who will help me save the Unions from Wall Street?

Not I, said the Rich Man, for I am a Pig  Oink Oink

Not I, said the Congress, for our Only Job is to Feed the Pig

Well then, please, who will help me save the Constitution?

Not I, said the Supreme Court, for Money makes the Laws

And certainly not I, said all the Corporations, for We are The People now

And We have spoken

Well, please, oh please, who will help me save the Elderly,

The Children, the Homeless, the Sick and Suffering,

The Animals, the Wilderness, the Under-Educated,

The Migrant Workers and Immigrants, the Legal Aid

For the Wrongly Accused and the Preyed Upon?

Who will help me save the Planet, for It is Dying?

Well now, Lady, said Rick Santorum, I will help you save

The Under-Educated, for They are the backbone

Of our Democracy, and what I hope all Americans

Will aspire to be, for It will keep them safe from Knowledge,

From Reality, from Thinking about all the Things

You go on and on about, Things that make people

Feel Sad and Oppressed and Hopeless and Unable

To get Enthused about Shopping and Buying Stuff,

And I will make it Politically Correct for the Under-Educated

To be In Vogue, and, rather than Educate Americans,

I will work toward creating a Nation So Stupid

That other Nations will fear to speak to us Intelligently

About Issues, lest They be Bombed Into Oblivion,

For a Nation doesn’t need Smart People, a Nation

Needs Smart Bombs, which will do our Thinking for us

Oh, but please, please, PLEASE, Mr. Santorum

Won’t You help me save a little teeny-tiny piece of Humanity?

Not I, said Rick Santorum, for Humanity doesn’t have The Vote

But Stupid People do

Peter Buknatski

Montpelier, Vt.

ARELIGIOUS GOVERNANCE

I am a protestant christian, but who cares. Our political agenda should not be framed based on any particular religion or religious beliefs.  Integrity, morality, humanity, and honesty are not synonymous with evangelicalism or any other religious movement. Religion is a personal choice, and one of our great freedoms is the separation of church and state.  

The Republican party’s decline started after being hijacked by the fanatical evangelical right movement.  When you interject religious zealotry into politics the result is a movement toward a religious dictatorship or aristocracy, with a focus on personal choice matters that should be left to individuals.

We need to elect people who recognize the need to reduce and limit government in our lives; who understand that our country is on the brink of financial disaster and are willing to cut spending; and most of all, who are honest, moral, have integrity and care for all human beings, regardless of their religious preference.

Updated: Return of the Dog Whistle Chorus

Mr. Lisman’s name has been clattering in our heads for a while now.  Finally, the penny has dropped…actually two pennies and a plugged nickel.

“Campaign for Vermont’s” frontman and the below-mentioned Angelo Pizzagalli both figure in one of part-time auditor/ part-time Boy Wonder Tom Salmon‘s temporary distractions from Job One.  

You might recall that, in the fall of 2010, Mr. Salmon released a “situation report” on the dairy industry in Vermont.

Apparently the job of auditor required so little of his attention that he found the resources to conduct a summer-long think-tank on agricultural policy; the goal being to generate three bang-up great ideas

“to increase agriculture related profits by $500 million by 2016.”

His hand-picked team of collaborators was long on Republican businessmen and short on farmers.  Among those Republican businessmen were Mr. Lisman and Mr. Pizzagalli, and of course Rich Tarrant.  

By the way; whatever happened to those bang-up great ideas?



……………………………………………………………………………………….

Early in December, jvwalt took a first  and second look at the so-called “Campaign for Vermont.”

What he found under the guise of “non-partisan” Vermont hugs, was a chorus of familiar dog whistles clearly intended to prick Republican ears while leaving everyone else none the wiser.  

It seems not so much a “Campaign for Vermont,”  as it does a “Campaign for Battleground Vermont” in the coming election year.

With businessman Bruce Lisman as the ubiquitous frontman, the Campaign for Vermont lists on its website a roster of businessmen that looks suspiciously like it might have been handed down directly from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and is described as “founding partners.”  

Now a second “Campaign for Vermont” voice has been heard from: one James Pizzagalli.

Appearing tonight in the Messenger (and, no doubt, coming soon to a paper near you)  Mr. Pizzagalli’s letter to the editor praises to the skies the founders of Campaign for Vermont, without mentioning his possible bias due to the fact that Angelo Pizzagalli  is listed on the website as one of those founders.  

If there could be any doubt left as to the legitimacy of “Campaign for Vermont”s “non-partisan” claim, the debut of this letter on Vermont Tiger let the cat and her whole litter of kittens out of the bag.

This iteration is much more to the point than Mr. Lisman’s rather innocuous debut.  Take a look at a few nuggets:

Perhaps without knowing it, but in countless ways, Vermonters in sufficient numbers to control the agenda of the State have taken us in a direction that is contrary to economic growth, job creation and economic prosperity.

Woof!

When job creators are prevented from growing, workers disappear. When entrepreneurship is not rewarded, others states reap those benefits.

Woof-woof!

We should ensure all citizens have some skin in the game. And we should ensure that the high standards of our environmental ethic continue to be achieved but not to the detriment of pragmatic outcomes.

Woof-woof-woof…SNAP!

Alpo time.

…Or could it be Super PAC time?

Not so crazy

As you’ve probably already heard, the attempt to override Governor Shumlin’s veto from last May – a veto of what had been a non-controversial, bipartisan bill to require newly drilled wells and wells being sold with a home purchase to be tested for contaminates such as arsenic – failed. At the time, lawmakers expressed shock at the move, as the administration could have expressed concerns at any point in the process, but instead opted for the last minute veto.

Shumlin’s objection was that the $100 or so cost this imposed on new wells and home sales was too much. Since $100 on a new home sale is barely a drop in the bucket, it’s more likely that the Governor saw it as an opportunity to get some press on his no new taxes commitment.

When the veto override came up for a vote, Majority Leader Campbell asked Senators to vote against in, and instead support a new version of the legislation which will be more to Shumlin’s liking.

All but one Senator dutifully did as they were told – the one exception was blogmeister Philip Baruth, Democrat of Chittenden County. I asked him about it afterwards, and he told me he simply saw no reason not to vote in support of a good bill – even if he’s going to vote for the new version as well.

Actually, he put it more concisely than that. Said Baruth:

“Call me crazy, but I’m anti-arsenic.”

Pollina warns Shumlin

In an excellent piece from Hallenbeck at the Freeps yesterday, Senator Anthony Pollina, a nominal Democrat who maintains his status as Progressive Party leader had words for Governor Shumlin as he enters his first re-election year:

“We’re still balancing the budget on the backs of average families,” Pollina said, noting Shumlin oversaw $37 million in budget cuts to human services, raised fees on health care providers and opposed efforts by Pollina and others to raise taxes on wealthy Vermonters instead.

“I think he looks like Jim Douglas,” Pollina said, referring to Shumlin’s Republican predecessor.

This is the second time Anthony Pollina has made such noises, but Shumlin may not be listening given the content elsewhere in the piece:

A little more than a year ago, Frank Cioffi hosted a news conference in his St. Albans barn where he and several other Democrats announced their support for Republican gubernatorial candidate Brian Dubie.

[…] Halfway into Shumlin’s two-year term as governor, Cioffi has changed his tune.

“I think he’s doing really well,” Cioffi, president of the Greater Burlington Industrial Corp., said of Shumlin. Cioffi said he’ll be backing Shumlin in the 2012 election.

Shumlin – who has clearly made a calculated position to push hard on a couple marquee progressive priorities and tack rightward on tax and fiscal policy, as well as some social services issues – has to be looking at that story and saying “mission accomplished.”

In any event, it means a major shift for the sidebar oddsmaker…

Throwing A Tub To The Whale

(Bumped. Bulk of content transplanted under fold.   – promoted by kestrel9000)

 Statism, schmatism.  Gimme free bananas!

Ron Paul's a racist, homophobic nutjob who has no realistic chance of winning the GOP nomination, let alone the Presidency, but he's probably the candidate that infuriates and scares me more than any other, even historian/paleontologist Newt Gingrich.  I think it mostly comes from his Blind Squirrel capacity, finding a nut every once in a while (war is bad, war on drugs is bad, Federal government can overreach), and the fact that otherwise smart people even on the left side of the 1D political spectrum fall for his so-called constitutionalism and consistency (I'm looking at you, Greenwald and Sirota).

As I have always said, I'm not a conlaw expert, but all citizens have a responsibility to determine the constitutionality of the policies and offices they support.  Yet this guy somehow has been elevated to guru status simply because he cries “Statist! Unconstitutional! Whiskey! Sexy!” every time he meets something–which is almost everything–he doesn't like*.

His fundamental “principle”: devolve things like civil rights/marriage/abortion to the states because they never, ever violate individual rights.  If the Constitution doesn't expressly say the Federal government can protect individual rights then clearly it's the states can do whatever they want, including infringing upon rights and the Feds have to stay out of it.  Notwithstanding little niggling details like “general welfare” and “necessary and proper” clauses, the Ninth and Fourteenth Amendments, etc.  

It's almost like he's never heard of any case law or precedent since 1789.  Or slavery.  Or Jim Crow.  Or the criminalization of sex between consenting adults.  Or state intrusions into a person's body.  Quite the libertarian, he.

I've been told by a Paulista whom I otherwise admire, all these silly things are irrelevent distractions.  Equal protection under the law is a distraction?  Driver, this is my stop.

The people who want to undo hard-won protections are the real distractions, not the Civil Rights Act.  The people who want to deny Fourteeth Amendment privileges and immunities are the real distractions, not marriage equality.  The people who want to let state governments stick their noses into your medicine cabinet, bedroom and uterus are the real distractions, not a woman's right to determine her own reproductive destiny.

One might call Paul's “states' rights” stance a dog whistle for obvious reasons, but I think of it as more as a “throwing a tub to a whale”.  Sure, bigots hear the code words, but it also diverts the attention of smart, well-meaning folks from Paul's real anti-libertarianism and his dubious constitutional reading and reasoning.

States rights?  Sure, I support the unique powers (and limitations) of the Several States per Article I, Article IV, Article V, the Ninth, the Tenth, etc.  They provide a check on Federal power and encroachment on individiual rights.  But to deny individual rights?  No.  Let's not forget that the central government also provides a check on the States. 

Our system is designed to not only create tension between branches, but the differing levels of government, each of which are jealous of their rights, keeping them focused on fending off power grabs from other quarters which safeguards our individual liberty.  Giving all responsibility and power to states is extreme and just as bad as having too strong a central government.  There's a reason we ditched the Articles of Confederation, Dr Paul.

Individual rights are the atomic unit of liberty.  States in the general sense are created to protect them.  As George Washington, in his capacity of president of the Philadelphia Convention, noted in his letter accompanying the new Constitution's transmittal to Congress:

It is obviously impracticable in the federal government of these states, to secure all rights of independent sovereignty to each, and yet provide for the interest and safety of all: Individuals entering into society, must give up a share of liberty to preserve the rest. The magnitude of the sacrifice must depend as well on situation and circumstance, as on the object to be obtained. It is at all times difficult to draw with precision the line between those rights which must be surrendered, and those which may be reserved…

How Lockean!  We all have natural rights to ourselves, property and fruits of our labor–perhaps Dr Paul has heard about such things herehere or here–but we cede a certain portion to government (e.g., the right to not be taxed, or as libertarians call it, not be robbed) so that we might increase our overall protection.  The formula is a difficult one and there is no single way to achieve this, but we work hard to create constitutions that try balancing individual rights and the powers necessary for government to protect them.

Democracy and republic forms of government are messy and full of conflict between individuals and their rights.  Because this formula is complicated, simplistic solutions like throwing most everything to the states are only recipes for disaster.

At a time when we should be pooling national resources–our money, our energy, our innovation–to address real problems like the jobs crisis, crumbling infrastructure, our unsustainable energy portfolio, global climate change, etc, don't be distracted by cranks who glibly suggest we toss out two centuries of progress.

ntodd

* A fun example: Paul “asserts that Congress had no power to impose a direct income tax.”

Now, it's true that Article I, Section 9 says, “No capitation, or other direct, Tax shall be laid, unless in Proportion to the Census or Enumeration…”  Guess he must've missed this amendment languageThe Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.  Is he really saying text of the Constitution is unconstitutional?

 

Before Baby 2012 loses its innocence, let’s offer a few nice words

This space (and my portion thereof) is usually given over to snark, sarcasm, and criticism, in various combinations. But there’ve been a few good-news stories lately, and I’d like to take the time on this newest, freshest day of the year to offer some thanks and gratitude. (Possibly seasoned by just a pinch of snark. Gotta be me.)

— Hooray for the opening of the new Champlain bridge! It took just a bit more than two years, and came in just a bit over budget. All in all, a pretty darn remarkable accomplishment.  Y’know, when government works, it can do some really nice things.

Snark: Hopefully, New York will be a little more diligent about inspection and upkeep this time.

— Three cheers for the beefing-up of the LIHEAP funds for this winter. (It’s gonna get cold sooner or later, right?) Our Congressional delegation, and the Shumlin Administration, did some good work in pumping more money into this crucial program.

Snark: Congrats to Jeb Spaulding for doing his part in this, despite the perfidious attempt by VSEA to distract his attention.  

— Finally, good-on-ya to the DOT and all the hard-working road crews for reopening Route 107, the last highway shut down by Tropical Storm Irene. It’s quite an accomplishment, getting all that done under very urgent circumstances, in what would usually be the tail end of the road-construction season. (And an assist to global warming for the late onset of winter that helped make it possible.)

Snark: We’ll see how the rivers and streams deal with the consequences of various unpermitted construction activities. Still, IMO, while I’m sure some unfortunate things were done, it was a rare situation when some shortcutting was called for.

Here’s to 2012 (cuz 2011 royally sucked)

I’m not jumping up and down to celebrate New Year’s Eve this time around. In fact, I’ll be lucky if I make it to watch the ball drop on teevee at midnight.

It’s not that I’m not happy about the coming of 2012. Quite the contrary. Partly it’s just that I’m old and boring now. I’m trying to grow some facial hair to make myself less boring, but that’s not going so well. Mainly I just look like I need to wash my face.

But the main reason I’m not in happy-happy-noisemaker mode is that I’m tired. 2011 absolutely kicked my ass.

And it’s not just me. Really, get Julie, kestrel or Maggie talking about their years. Seems like most people I know had a tough year. Weird how so often good and bad years seem to be so shared.

But health, injuries, up-and-down employment, couple of casualties – all that stuff was there, but it kinda sucked beyond the personal, too. There was Irene and Fukushima. There’s another winter that’s way too warm and wet, suggesting climate change is on the fastest possible track anybody could’ve imagined. The Iraq War is sorta-kinda-mostly over, and that’s a great thing – but in other policy spheres, the Tea Party has managed to grind government to an absolute standstill.

But 2012 is an election year, and election years are different. The sense of flux that surrounds elections seems to trickle down into the rest of society. Cynicism ticks up, sure – but also the sense that anything is possible (and I suppose those two things are the flip sides of each other). Things happen on election years.

So with all the oomph I can muster, I sez “bring it on, 2012!”

I mean, seriously – it can’t be any worse, right?

Well, there is that end-of-the-world thing.