mug     



Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?

Search




Advanced Search


Active Users
Currently 1 user(s) logged on.



Follow us on Twitter! or join our Facebook group!

Feeling the Heat

by: Sue Prent

Thu Jul 22, 2010 at 00:00:00 AM EDT


There are plenty of distortions and inaccuracies finding their way into the public forum these days, so it is doubly important that our sterling roster of Democratic gubernatorial candidates remain scrupulous about their facts.  If not, there may be hell to pay.  This week, when the Shumlin campaign made certain questionable assertions of primacy in the area of single-payor healthcare advocacy,  Matt Dunne's campaign responded by crying "foul:"
In a mailing sent out to Vermonters this week, Shumlin writes," "I am the only candidate in this race who has sponsored a single payer health care bill..."
Similarly, in a response to questions from the Burlington Free Press on Vermont's social safety net, Shumlin writes "I am the only candidate who sponsored a single-payer health care bill."

However, in the 1993-1994 Legislative Session, House Bill 0763 titled, "Vermont Health Security Plan/Single-Payer Health Plan" was co-sponsored by several House Members including Matt Dunne. In fact, Dunne has had a long history supporting single payer health care legislation and his current health-care plan is based on a single payer system.

The Dunne campaign is asking the Shumlin campaign for a public apology.  It is also demanding that a Dunne-approved correction from Shumlin be sent (at  Shumlin's expense) to all the voters who received the original mailer that contained the erroneous statement.

Sue Prent :: Feeling the Heat
Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Raise Your Voice!
Feeling the Heat | 9 comments
It's worth pointing out (4.00 / 2)
 That when this was called to Shumlin's attention he conceded the point.

From WCAX last night:

Shumlin says during that conversation he "apologized that we missed that 17 years ago Matt sponsored a single-payer health care bill that never came off the wall, but we need all the friends we can get in this battle and we're delighted that he did"

Shumlin says his research team missed the bill partially because it never went anywhere. He would not say if he plans to send out a corrected postcard mailing and as far as a public retraction, joked that by speaking with WCAX he did make a public retraction.

I didn't hear Peter offer to send a new mailing to correct the original misstatement, though.


The response was (0.00 / 0)
Basically "Yeah I guess he was signed on to some bill that went no where, can't blame my research guys from not finding that, do I not have to talk about this again?" I thought he seemed pretty incredulous about the whole ordeal

mbreuer.vt@gmail.com

[ Parent ]
Agreed (4.00 / 1)
Yes, they're running against each other in a primary, but I found Peter's "apology" insincere at best.  His critique is that Dunne's Bill didn't go anywhere? as opposed to Peter's Bills on Single Payer I guess?

And thus why I'd never come anywhere close to supporting Peter, despite the fact that he may be better positioned than most to beat Dubya- er, Dubie- one on one: Peter's an insincere shmuk who acts on one instinct: where can this get me?

"GMD's once proud libertarian-socialist"


[ Parent ]
Thanks, Jack! (0.00 / 0)
I missed that broadcast.

single payer (0.00 / 0)
Matt Dunne has been in this campaign for several months.  I never heard him announce that he co-sponsored a "single payer" bill.  There has been plenty of time for him to get the word out that 17 years ago he co-sponsored this bill.  But, he didn't bring this up until a few days ago.  And, in fact, I have not heard Matt Dunne use the term "single payer" but instead he has used the euphemism "self-insurance."

Not to quabble about words, though, if Matt is enthusiastic about single payer, he should have been announcing the fact that he co-sponsored a single payer bill a long time ago.  

As for Peter Shumlin's campaign, it would not be easy to catch a bill that was written 17 years ago, which Matt Dunne was not the lead sponsor of, and which was never even considered in committee.

I think Peter Shumlin's apology is fine if he missed this fact, and I don't see why Matt Dunne didn't advertise this fact long ago in any case if he is supporter of a single payer system.

As for questionning the character of a rival in a primary, I personally think we should stick to the issues.  If your opponent misses a fact, then just correct the record.


Dunne's been advocating for single-payer for some time now (4.00 / 1)
I'm pretty sure he said something about it in the forum I live blogged and I think he even mentioned his co-sponsoring of a connected bill way back when.  It's not like this is something no one ever heard of until now.  I can see how Shumlin wouldn't remember this (a lot of people talk at those forums and if you're a participant in one, you're probably busy trying to plan your next comment while others are talking), but I don't blame Dunne for jumping on this.  

Musician, Web Designer, Photographer

[ Parent ]
I think this is a good reminder to all candidates (4.00 / 1)
to be careful about using words like "only" and "never."  Absolutes are minefields of potential error.

[ Parent ]
Yes, but (0.00 / 0)
You are right Sue, but the the fact that Racine is the ONLY Democratic candidate who has beaten Dubie is still true!

[ Parent ]
I believe you are right on that one! (0.00 / 0)
;)

[ Parent ]
Feeling the Heat | 9 comments

GMD Links

Vermont Daily Briefing
Rational Resistance
VT News Guy
VT Digger
Minor Heresies
What's the Point?
Vermont Yankee, evacuation plans, & more
Mulish Behavior
Political Animal (with Steve Benen)
Reason and Brimstone
Blazing Indiscretions
sneigwh
Dohiyi Mir
Blier Watch
five before chaos
Blue Hampshire
Blue News Tribune
Burlington Pol
Norsehorse
Rip & Read
Integral Psychosis
VT Secession
Tenselblog
VT Bloggernaut
Morgan's Gov. race blog
Bureaucracy Blog
Austanspace

Non-political

Candleblog
iBrattleboro
WKVT 1490 AM
Vermont Mornings
False 45th
Bosox Wally

National

Congress Matters
Daily Kos
Open Left
BlogPac
Talking Points Memo
My Left Wing
MyDD
Docudharma
Glenn Greenwald
Firedoglake
Atrios (Eschaton)
Think Progress
Driftglass
Pam's House Blend
Hullabaloo (Digby)
The Plum Line (Sargent)

Legacy Media Blogs

Vermont View
vt buzz
Blurt (7 Days)

International

The Irish Independent
Comment is free...(Guardian UK)
Al Jazeera
Pulse Media
Global Voices
All Voices
Vermonters for a Just Peace in Israel/Palestine




Specialized Feeds:

Google Reader or Homepage
Add to My Yahoo!
Subscribe with Bloglines
Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Add to My AOL
Subscribe in Rojo
R|Mail
Add to Technorati Favorites!


RSS FEED

250-1

75-1


blog advertising is good for you
Event Calendar
February 2012
(view month)
S M T W R F S
* * * 01 02 03 04
05 06 07 08 09 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 * * *
<< (add event) >>



Featured Stories
State and Local
National and International




Powered by: SoapBlox