Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?

Beyond the human price of Donald Trump’s promise to deport undocumented immigrants, there will be an economic price to pay. It is estimated that one quarter of Vermont’s farm labor force could be impacted by the new administrations anti-immigrant policies.

When milking crews and field workers are forced to leave the country, who will do the work of feeding America?

The conversation has already begun between the Agency of Agriculture, Food and Markets and the Department of Corrections around the possibility of deploying a prison workforce to ensure that there are sufficient hands available to get the job done.

In Vermont, such a workforce probably stands a better chance of experiencing fair treatment and reasonable compensation than in more regressive states. In most states where prisoners have been made to work on farms to replace lost migrant help, the experience has been less than satisfactory, as the captive laborers tend to lack the work ethic, skill and efficiency of the immigrant workforce they replace, and compensation, such as it is, goes mostly to prison operators.

Paid or unpaid, such an arrangement would amount to slave labor supporting a cornerstone Vermont industry.

It’s too easy to rationalize away fair labor practices and compensation for people who have broken the law, no matter how minor their offense might have been.

We already have the highest incarceration rate of any advanced nation, reflecting a draconian inclination that does not become us. Rather than working to reduce prison populations as most people agree should be done, if states begin to rely on prison labor for their food supply, we might actually see a systemic reluctance to pursue alternatives to imprisonment.  Furthermore, when prison labor is charged with animal care, the results can be unsettling:

In March 2012, officials in Sutter County, California discussed ending prison work crews for a different reason. For decades, prisoners have been used to feed dogs and cats, clean their cages and even assess their health at the county’s animal shelter. Over the past five years multiple reports have cited shortcomings with the use of prison labor because prisoners, who are not trained in veterinarian care, have caused problems at the shelter by making mistakes and distracting employees….A 2007 grand jury report found that prisoners were partially responsible for an “abnormally” high number of animal deaths at the shelter.

This is of special concern in Vermont where dairying represents a significant portion of our farm labor needs.

During a forum on labor rights in Columbus, Georgia on April 4, 2012, Richard Jessie, second vice president of the Columbus NAACP, noted that “Our prison workforce is an enslaved workforce basically.” Commenting on the money the city saves by using prisoner work crews, which is reportedly $9 million to $17 million annually, he added, “We use slave labor to do much of the work that could and should be paid jobs.”

A prison workforce should not be Vermont’s fall-back plan for addressing labor shortages down on the farm. Efficiently maintaining our food supply requires physically challenging labor and more than a small amount of commitment to the work. An immigrant workforce has traditionally provided these qualities in exchange for relatively modest compensation.

Our entire food system has been built on those expectations and Americans would be very foolish to abandon the effort for meaningful immigration reform that would support their continued participation in our economy. If we begin to erode that compact now with an “emergency” use of prison labor, we may never be able to rebuild a timelessly valuable labor system again, and, given the regressive inclinations of the Trump contingent, could even live to see defacto slavery return to America.

Prison labor is not the answer.

About Sue Prent

Artist/Writer/Activist living in St. Albans, Vermont with my husband since 1983. I was born in Chicago; moved to Montreal in 1969; lived there and in Berlin, W. Germany until we finally settled in St. Albans.

2 thoughts on “Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?

  1. One of the dirty secrets here is that “sanctuary” is code for harboring criminal immigrants here unlawfully in the first place and now creating a situation where LE is prevented from enforcing our crime statutes on a particular class of ppl & a reverse form of discrimination by enforcing those same stautes on the rest of us, which I don’t think many citizens are aware of, supposing that these are otherwise law abiding individuals which is the real reason for the alarm in VT — they know that they are harboring criminals.

    As it exists the only way they can be busted here in VT at least is if record is known to local/state LE & presence is reported to ICE, or if stopped for another offense & previous record pops up on the radar.

    These not individuals who merely wander into our fair state to feed struggling families in other poverty-stricken countries but are matched by brokers to businesses who are trafficking in a modern-day slave trade. The reason for the rogue judge order halting Trumps’ EO is very likely at the behest of the wealthy business owners, tech companies and other employers importing illegals & refugees from poverty-stricken countries which is included in this modern form of slavery which is hurting residents who need and want to work and in larger cities heavily impacting racial minorities esp youth.

    This means that while our young men & women who may have committed the same or far lesser crimes, some with untreated mental illnesses, have ended up dying due to neglect sometimes simply awaiting trial. Others are shipped out of state to perversely for-profit trade to facilities far away from family, friends & support systems to Michigan & Kentucky, who take only the least violent and least sick, leaving the costly & most ill here in VT.

    Other extremely violent criminals– sex offenders, drug traffickers and gang members languish in prison while their immigrant counterparts live free picking vegetables, milking cows & work for businesses — otherwise gainfully employed — who could and should be using citizens. Or continuing to offend and engage in gang & criminal activitity. Their felonies are reduced to keep them under the radar while continuing to be a threat to public safety.

    The “they do work that our citizens won’t do” is a canard & complete bullshit. We have labor laws and costs to employers for employees. Illegals must work for whatever the’re paid under any conditions, do as the’re told or are out of a job. The biggest reason the’re so attractive is due to their exploitablity.

    Prisoners could do far worse than being employed and given work experience & something better to do besides prison-sleeping & taking out their pent up rage on each other and the guards. And, they’re already working for businesses in VT as evidenced by the signs in those businesses telling us so.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *