Updated: Normgate

After writing the letter to the Messenger, I learned that the two legislators who shared an apartment with Mr. McAllister belonged to opposing parties…one Democrat and one Republican.  I apologise for having given the impression that both were Republicans and have sent a revised letter to the Messenger.  

That being said, I don’t think we should focus so much on the partisan nature of who should have known and who didn’t.  The point is that, over the years since the reported behaviors began, there must have been evidence of inappropriate relationships and questionable behaviors for any number of people to remark upon.  It says something troubling about the  culture of privilege when McAllister’s status as a powerful figure in farming and as a state rep shielded him from greater scrutiny for so long.


This is cross-posted from Messenger letters, where my GMD colleague, Mike McCarthy, has been taking an inexplicable beating for his comments on the implications of Mr. McAllister’s fall from grace.

Since Mike McCarthy’s letter concerning Norm McAllister’s inevitable replacement appeared in the Messenger he has been the target of a stream of angry letters.

This makes absolutely no sense to me.  Where is his crime?

Mike McCarthy is not just the current chair of Franklin County Democrats, he is a young father whose anger is understandable when the victim is little more than a child herself.

I am not a Democrat; I am a Progressive.  I agree with Mike that Randy Brock should not be the only choice the Governor has from the GOP.  I would like to see Carolyn Branagan proposed for the seat.

She is a hard-working Republican legislator with plenty of practical experience and excellent people skills. Recently, she has played an important role in carrying forward the agenda to clean up Vermont’s troubled waterways.

She is also a woman; and considering the nature of Mr. McAllister’s alleged offenses, all of the women of Franklin County deserve more than just a token apology.

Under the circumstances, Rep. Branagan’s appointment would go a long way toward healing the Franklin County GOP and restoring confidence in our delegation.

This is important not just for the people who voted for Mr. McAllister but to all of his constituents, from all three parties.

Returning to Mike McCarthy’s original letter.  I did not interpret it, as some were quick to do, as a condemnation of all Republican legislators.  I believe he was referring to the fact that two of Mr. McAllister’s

colleagues who shared an apartment with him in Montpelier were aware of the fact that a very young girl…a child to most of us… was sleeping in his bedroom.  

If those two gentlemen didn’t question that arrangement, they are either incredibly stupid or guilty of enabling the behavior at the very least.  We don’t need to know whether or not Mr. McAllister can be charged under the language of any particular criminal code to know that this simply was wrong.  He was a much, much older man in a position of power over her.  That, of and by itself, is enough to brand the relationship as non-consensual.

End of story.

One can only hope that the constituents of those other two lawmakers (and their own party) have the good sense to recognize that they have demonstrated a remarkable lack of judgement and sensitivity that essentially disqualifies them from reelection.

There is a culture of enabling which allowed Mr. McAllister to become what he has.  I don’t believe that he woke up at 60 years of age and suddenly became a sexual predator; and the suggestion by some that this behavior emerged from grief over his wife’s passing is at once unbelievable and utterly repulsive.

Let’s grow up and recognize that Mr. McAllister’s story should carry the lesson for all of us that there is exploitation of vulnerable people going on all around us, and apparently we need to do a much better job of knowing whom we entrust with representing us.  

About Sue Prent

Artist/Writer/Activist living in St. Albans, Vermont with my husband since 1983. I was born in Chicago; moved to Montreal in 1969; lived there and in Berlin, W. Germany until we finally settled in St. Albans.

9 thoughts on “Updated: Normgate

  1. Agree w/everything you said, was extremely well said and spoken w/your customary clarity. Thanks Sue for spittin it.

    They should both be fired along w/good-old-norm. It was in their power to have saved this young lady, who appears to be serving as not much more than a sex worker to GON under the guise of ‘assisting’ in his legislative duties from further abuse but willfully ignored it in all of its sordidness and in fact acted as enablers. Apparently unable to view this young lady as their own child which is particularly reprehensible.  

    Those who defend him are likely and quite obviously guilty of the same practices in other various capacities.

    We don’t need these f’king jerks representing us.  

  2. the one that they probably cast a vote upon and passed again, probably.   IF and a big IF, the story that the abuse started when she was under age, and again IF they were under the umbrella of the law, THEY could be charged themselves.  

    We can only wish that would be the case.    Doubtful.   Would have been great if the legislature would include the responsibility for this kind of stuff ONTO themselves…  again.. wishing.

  3. How many years ago did Rep. Rachel Weston file a complaint about McAllister’s ‘like to see you naked’ comment to her?  Six years?

    And her complaint was swept under the rug.  But if McAllister was acting like that years ago to a female Rep, well, I think MANY of his male colleagues were well aware that he was displaying sexual aggression and open lewdness that might have been just the tip of the iceberg, but  thought maybe that was OK because Weston was, what?–the youngest female Rep there, and wide open to sexual harassment?  (Did she look 12 or 13 years old?)

    I think a lot more of the BOYS there knew a lot more than we are currently hearing.

    6 years ago, the young lady intern McAllister brought to Montpelier from his ‘rape farm’ was 14.

    This should be a bigger story than we have so far been told.  There should be a question at any candidates forum next year:  “WHAT did you know, and WHEN did you know it?”

    Thank you, Sue, for addressing the ‘denials’ from McAllister’s Franklin County supporters.  Tell them many many people support Cosby also.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *