Milne: I won’t vilify Shumlin, but he’s a brazen, bullying, radical ultra-progressive

Crossposted at, you guessed it, The Vermont Political Observer.

Warm day in downtown Barre. Small crowd, mainly retirement age (Yr. Obdt. Svt. included) gathering on the front lawn of the Aldrich Public Library. The occasion? Scott Milne’s long-awaited launch of his gubernatorial candidacy.

Phil Scott was there. Jim Douglas was there. My frenemy Senator Joe Benning was there.

Who wasn’t there? Well, as far as I could tell, Barre’s Republican Mayor Thom Lauzon wasn’t there. And he usually manages to make himself conspicuous where the cameras gather. Interesting. I seem to recall Paul “The Huntsman” Heintz reporting that Lauzon and his wife donated $2,000 to Governor Shumlin’s campaign.

Checking… yes, yes he did.

Still, the front section of the library, comfortably air-conned, was full of Milne supporters and the legions of media desperately looking for a sure-fire story during the summer slump.

Milne was introduced by Douglas, who gave Mr. Bunny a hearty endorsement after delivering what sounded very much like a statement for his own candidacy. (Must’ve made the Republican audience wish for What Might Have Been; Douglas is their Beau Ideal.)

Douglas lauded Milne’s experience in “the real world” of business and commerce, someone “outside the bubble, unaffected by the stale air of the State House.” That’s rich, coming from a guy who spent virtually his entire adult life in that same stale air.

And then the Man of the Hour stepped to the plate, promising “a campaign of ideas” and said that he would “not be vilifying the Governor.”

In the following few minutes, Milne used these words in direct or indirect reference to the incumbent: questioning whether Shumlin’s course is “responsible and realistic,” calling the Governor’s agenda “ultra-progressive,” referring to Shumlin as “headstrong about the need for exuberance and rapid, radical change,:’ said the Administration was one of “unbridled experimentation,” decried “bullying tactics” and “brazen displays of power.”

But he won’t be “vilifying” the Governor. Bwahahaha.  

Milne depicted himself as moderate, “cautious,” “responsible,” and reluctant to make any wholesale changes. He said “cautious” a bunch of times.

The strategy, thus, becomes clear: in order to capture the center, Milne will go all-out to portray Shumlin as a fire-breathing radical. Without, of course, vilifying him in any way.

It’s hard to see this working. Shumlin spends far too much time courting the center and catering to the business community to be convincingly marginalized as an “ultra-progressive.” (When he said that, I could almost hear the guffaws exploding from Prog Central: “Shumlin a progressive? You must be joking!”)

After his speech, his crew made their way to the Elks Club next door for a hamburger lunch. It took Milne a while to get there; he first had to submit himself to his first media scrum. The key point for me was the inevitable exchange about Act 250, given his frustration and anger over the regulatory troubles facing his dream project, the mixed-use Quechee Highlands development. It’s run afoul of the regional Act 250 board and the town of Hartford.

Milne claimed that he is “very supportive of the concept of Act 250,” but then accused Shumlin of “hijacking something into a political ideology rather than a practical program that needs to be applied more pragmatically.”

Not exactly grammatical, but you get his drift. But when asked for specifics on how the Administration had hijacked the process, Milne came up short of the mark:

“I think if you look between the poor management at the Agency of Commerce over the last four years, very poor management at the Agency of Natural Resources, there’s very evidential answers right there.”

Not much meat on those bones, is there? He charges the Administration with “hijacking” the process — an aggressive power grab — and all he can offer as proof is a nonspecific charge of “poor management.”

Hey, a travel agent ought to know that it takes positive, organized action to hijack anything. You don’t do it by accident.

The Milne kickoff was a happy event for the true believers. But if this is the tack he’s going to take, he’s gonna get shellacked by the Governor.


2 thoughts on “Milne: I won’t vilify Shumlin, but he’s a brazen, bullying, radical ultra-progressive

  1. in his Seven Days piece that explored Mr. Milne’s counterintuitive approach to campaigning by bad-mouthing the state of Vermont.

    He also very courteously gave a tip of the hat to our own BP and GMD for first bringing to light Mr. Milne’s fascinating campaign finance “club.”  

    For that especially, we’d like to return the favor!

  2. Milne certainly has been well trained by the anti-American Conservative Republicans.  Describe your Democratic opponent’s moderate-right political position as extremist, hard-left, ignore the gales of laughter and then demand that everyone accept the lie as fact.

    Wel, OK, Shumlin supports a few things that are left-of-center, but overall, he’s to the right of the center line…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *